Decision Tree for Metal Speciation Guidelines - (see WQG page 3.4-19)
For metals or metalloids in fresh waters (up to 2500 mgL-1 salinity), consider the effect of hardness, pH and alkalinity on toxicity and derive a hardness-modified trigger value (HMTV)a using the appropriate algorithm from table 3.4.3. Table 3.4.4 indicates how the trigger values vary with different ranges of hardness but extra care is needed for waters with hardness below 25 mgL-1 CaCO3. If samples have been filtered, for comparison with the HMTV, this will also take into account suspended organic matter. The hardness algorithms (table 3.4.3) also account for pH.
The recommended decision scheme for metals is illustrated in below ( see Figure 3.4.2) but steps beyond the initial hardness adjustment are optional. If the total metal concentration in the unfiltered sample exceeds the HMTV, then users may choose one or more of four steps:
(i) compare metal concentration with the HMTV after filtering the original unacidified sample through a 0.45 µm membrane filter. An alternative is to proceed directly to measuring filtered concentrations instead of totals initially.
(ii) proceed to more complex estimates of metal bioavailability (step 10) relating to the study site;
(iii) accept that the guideline has been exceeded and institute management action;
(iv) proceed to DTA (step 12).
|
_________________________________________
/
\
|
_________________________________________
|
/
\
|
|
|
_________________________________________
/
\
|
|
|
|
|
|
_________________________________________
/
\
|
|
_________________________________________
/
\
 Test against guideline value
 Compare metal total concentration (acid suluable)
 with relevant  and guideline 'trigger' value
  Low Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
  # Potential Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
<<<< Level below guideline value
Level exceeds guideline value >>>>
 Correct Guideline for hardness
 (Note: Applies to freshwaters only)
<<<< Level below modified guideline value
Level exceeds modified guideline value >>>>
  Low Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
  # Potential Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
 Test against modified guideline value
 Test dissolved metal concentration against new guideline value
 (filtration through a 0.45 micro m or smaller membrane)
<<<< Level below modified guideline value
Level exceeds modified guideline value >>>>
  Low Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
  # Potential Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
 Consider Metal Speciation
 Speciation  modelling
 Chemical  measurement
 Test 'bioavailable' metal concentration  against new guideline value
  Low Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
  # High Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
 Biological effects assessment  ( e.g. Direct Toxicity Assessment )
<<<< Level below modified guideline value
Level exceeds modified guideline value >>>>
<<<< Non Toxic
Toxic>>>>
  Low Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
  High Risk of Damage
  or Impairment of Use
 (Initiate remedial actions)
 #  Further investigations are not mandatory;
     users may opt to proceed to management or remedial actions.